Learning Performance-Improving Code Edits

With the decline of Moore's law, optimizing program performance has become a major focus of software research. However, high-level optimizations such as API and algorithm changes remain elusive due to the difficulty of understanding the semantics of code. Simultaneously, pretrained large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated strong capabilities at solving a wide range of programming tasks. To that end, we introduce a framework for adapting LLMs to high-level program optimization. First, we curate a dataset of performance-improving edits made by human programmers of over 77,000 competitive C++ programming submission pairs, accompanied by extensive unit tests. A major challenge is the significant variability of measuring performance on commodity hardware, which can lead to spurious "improvements." To isolate and reliably evaluate the impact of program optimizations, we design an environment based on the gem5 full system simulator, the de facto simulator used in academia and industry. Next, we propose a broad range of adaptation strategies for code optimization; for prompting, these include retrieval-based few-shot prompting and chain-of-thought, and for finetuning, these include performance-conditioned generation and synthetic data augmentation based on self-play. A combination of these techniques achieves a mean speedup of 6.86$\times$ with eight generations, higher than average optimizations from individual programmers (3.66$\times$). Using our model's fastest generations, we set a new upper limit on the fastest speedup possible for our dataset at 9.64$\times$ compared to using the fastest human submissions available (9.56$\times$).

Authors

• Alexander Shypula
• Aman Madaan
• Yimeng Zeng
• Uri Alon 0002
• Jacob R. Gardner
• Yiming Yang 0002
• Milad Hashemi
• Graham Neubig
• Parthasarathy Ranganathan
• Osbert Bastani
• Amir Yazdanbakhsh

Keywords

• Large Language Models
• Retrieval Augmented Generation
• Program Synthesis
• Program Optimization
• Fine-Tuning
• Goal-Conditioning
• Data Augmentation
• Self-Play
• Synthetic Dataset
• Performance Optimization
• Machine Learning for Code Optimization
• Dataset