Resolving distributed knowledge

In epistemic logic, a key formal theory for reasoning about knowledge in AI and other fields, different notions of group knowledge describe different ways in which knowledge can be associated with a group of agents. Distributed knowledge can be seen as the sum of the knowledge in a group; it is sometimes referred to as the potential knowledge of a group, or the joint knowledge they could obtain if they had unlimited means of communication. In epistemic logic, a formula of the form D G φ is intended to express the fact that group G has distributed knowledge of φ, that the total information in the group can be used to infer φ. In this paper we show that this is not the same as φ necessarily being true after the members of the group actually share all their information with each other – perhaps contrary to intuitive ideas about what distributed knowledge is. We furthermore introduce a new operator R G, such that R G φ means that φ is true after G have shared all their information with each other – after G's distributed knowledge has been resolved. The R G operators are called resolution operators. We study logics with different combinations of resolution operators and operators for common and distributed knowledge. Of particular interest is the relationship between distributed and common knowledge. The main results are characterizations of expressive power, and sound and complete axiomatizations. We also study the relationship to public announcement logic.

Authors

• Thomas Ågotnes
• Yì N. Wáng

Keywords

• Epistemic logic
• Distributed knowledge
• Expressivity
• Axiomatization