EAAI Journal 2026 Journal Article
A note on “Optimizing the selection of the secret parameters for public key cryptosystems by using interval linear programming and fully fuzzy linear programming”
- Raina Ahuja
- Parul Tomar
- Amit Kumar
- S.S. Appadoo
Bas (Eng. Appl. Artif. Intell. (2025) 144 (110168)) claimed that, to the best of their knowledge, no mathematical programming-based method has been proposed in the literature to determine optimal secret parameters of public key cryptosystems in an interval or fuzzy environment. To fill this gap, Bas proposed an interval mathematical programming problem (IMPP) and a fuzzy mathematical programming problem (FMPP) for the Rivest, Shamir, Adleman (RSA) public key cryptosystem. Bas also proposed a method to solve IMPP as well as a method to solve FMPP. In these methods, firstly, IMPP and FMPP are transformed into crisp mathematical programming problem (CMPP). Then, using an optimal solution of the transformed CMPP, an optimal solution of original IMPP and FMPP is obtained. In this note, it is pointed out that the subtraction operation of triangular fuzzy numbers (TFNs), used in the method to transform FMPP into CMPP, is not valid. Due to which the transformed CMPP is not equivalent to the original FMPP. Hence, Bas's method to solve FMPP is not valid in its present form. Keeping the same in mind, Bas's method is modified by replacing the invalid subtraction operation of TFNs with the valid subtraction operation. Furthermore, using the modified method, correct results for the RSA public key cryptosystem corresponding to existing data, considered by Bas to illustrate their proposed method, are obtained. It is pertinent to mention that the subtraction operation of intervals, used in Bas's method to transform IMPP into CMPP, is valid.